Outsourcing Leadership Blog

Outsourcing Leadership Blog

John Kitchen

One Sourcing Deal, Three Wins

Posted by John Kitchen on Wednesday, 28 October 2009 15:12
Categories: Strategy

It occurred to me the other day there was a time when outsourcing providers would cringe when they heard a sourcing advisor had been retained by a client or prospect.  But I don’t think that is the case any longer, nor should it be.  In fact, I believe that the news should be met with optimism, and not just because the buyer is sending clearer signals regarding making a sourcing decision.

Companies looking to begin a sourcing journey, whether outsourcing their IT infrastructure or applications or sourcing a mix of business processes, desire a well-crafted deal that will optimize their goals.  Providers used to think that an advisor in the mix would lengthen the time until a deal is struck.  I offer the opposite is true.  Advisors bring to the table structure and project management acumen that will assist their clients by quickly determining key sourcing decisions and an overall streamlining of the project.

I contend providers will benefit the same as buyers do when an advisor has been engaged.  

For the most part this is true because there should be expectations of a sustainable deal that align the interests of all the parties while allowing the best value to be obtained.  Let me break this down into three points:

1.    Deal Alignment – Advisors have a structured process that will define all the critical elements of a potential sourcing award.  Careful analysis of operations or process is explored to determine their source-ability against client specific criteria.  This allows a potential RFP to be focused only on towers or services the client will consider sourcing and not flood the market with unnecessary RFI requests.
2.    Achieving Desired Value – Potential value leakage is always a concern after a deal is struck.  Without properly operationalizing the agreement, potential for the achievement of desired value decreases while the opportunity for a deal to derail increases.  This is likely the beginning of every failed sourcing agreement that we read about.  In other words, the foundation of successful governance is critical.
3.    Sustainable Deal – I contend that with advisor-led sourcing agreements, deals are more likely to withstand market and business pressures over the term of the agreement.  Clients that are not well-versed with crafting sourcing agreements and providers that are may not always yield balanced or sustainable deals.

I think it is pretty safe to say that all parties evaluating a sourcing decision do not want to protract this process.  Rather they desire a deal that is successful for all the participants.   A deal that is crafted with an advisor is a win for the buyer, the provider and the advisor - one deal, three wins.

 
back to blog

Comments  

 
#3 John Kitchen 2009-11-13 08:57 Thank you for your comments; I am not alone in my thinking! :) I would very much like to hear more from a service provider perspective… please post your thoughts! Quote
 
 
#2 Fred Dempster 2009-11-09 12:52 One word describes any outsourcing: Complex. Sure I was concerned when I saw an advisor involved in a deal, at first. Quickly it became obvious that while price was an ingredient, the total picture of the deal was the goal. Just like system implementations , any company who does not do outsourcing deals every day is well-served by those who have done many. Quote
 
 
#1 Linda Merritt 2009-11-05 18:49 I have been talking with many in the HR outsourcing community and I have been surprised at the positive support from providers for use of advisors.

Especially for first time buyers, an advisor can help develop the requirements, guide realistic expectations and assist with short listing potential providers.

In the first generation of HR outsourcing deals, advisors were over focused on getting the lowest pricing for the client, which would more than cover their fees. In the end this did not serve the client or provider well if the deal was under priced and added costs created value leakage and strife.

Now sourcing advisors are more balanced in helping bring together deals that are good at signing and sustainable over time.
Quote
 

Add comment


Email address and website will not be displayed with your comment.

Post my comment anonymously


Twitter Feed

The Second Most Important Factor in an Outsourcing Agreement: Assuming that costs savings is the most important f... http://bit.ly/9EdCiQ